Menu of Krispy Pizza - New Brunswick, NJ in New Brunswick, New Jersey, USA

Menu Overview

Krispy Pizza in New Brunswick, NJ, stands as a cherished landmark for pizza lovers, especially those connected to Rutgers University. Nestled at 50 College Ave, this spot is beloved for its distinctively crisp crust, generous toppings, and warm, inviting atmosphere. The brand has carried a proud tradition since the late 1960s, producing pies that have become an essential part of local culture and late-night cravings.

The menu offers a rich variety of options, balancing classic favorites with inventive twists. If you are stopping by, the Pizza by the Slice is a must-try—each slice embodies the signature “krispy” texture that melts in your mouth yet offers a satisfying crunch. The Pepperoni Pizza Slice and the Margherita Pizza Slice stand out for their fresh ingredients and well-balanced flavors; the Margherita, in particular, earns high praise for its simplicity and authenticity, with a 4.5-star appreciation from guests. For those craving a bold profile, the Hot Honey Pepperoni Pesto Pizza delivers a sweet and spicy complexity, an innovative take that elevates traditional pepperoni to new heights.

Beyond pizza, the menu extends to an appealing selection of rolls such as the Stromboli, Cheesesteak, and the classic Pepperoni Roll, all priced uniformly at $11.30. Each roll packs layers of quality ingredients—melty mozzarella, robust tomato sauce, and flavorful meats or vegetables—making them a hearty alternative to pizza slices. Sides like Garlic Bread and Empanadas complement the meal well, adding variety and flavor dimensions to the experience.

The beverage lineup boasts popular 20oz drinks like Fanta, Coke, and Dr Pepper, each for $3.50, perfect to wash down the richly flavored dishes. A modest yet practical addition is the Cup of Sauce at $0.90, ideal for dipping and enhancing bites further.

Customer feedback spotlights Krispy Pizza’s authenticity and quality. Longtime local Joaquin Perez reminisces about its unmatched flavor and heat, proclaiming it the best pizza he’s ever had—an accolade hard to overlook. Other patrons note the family-like warmth from the staff and the vibrant energy that fills the small, campus-centered space. While seating may be limited, the fast, friendly service maintains a welcoming vibe that encourages repeat visits.

Some critiques mention that ordering by slice might not match the freshness of a whole pie, suggesting that a large pizza could offer a more perfect experience. Still, the menu’s variety and the consistent quality of ingredients keep Krispy Pizza a popular option among students and community members alike.

In essence, Krispy Pizza offers more than just food; it delivers a slice of New Brunswick tradition steeped in flavor, community, and heartfelt hospitality. Whether you opt for a classic cheese slice, a savory roll, or one of their inventive specialty pies, expect a meal that respects the heritage of true American pizza with a unique, crispy edge that keeps fans coming back.